Hindsight bias: Inventing memories & blaming victims

Tags

, , , , , , , ,

It’s not unusual for people to think that an outcome was inevitable after the fact, a phenomenon known as “hindsight bias”. This remains the case even when test subjects are instructed to ignore their knowledge of the outcome and rate the likeliness of several possible outcomes. Once an outcome is known, people tend to see causal links in antecedents (the events preceding the outcome); this builds into a causal chain that makes the outcome seem an inevitable consequence of the antecedents. Studies have shown that, in addition to constructing such links, people also tend to exercise selective memory, preferentially remembering details that are consistent with the seemingly inevitable outcome.  Linda Carli (of Wellesley College) conducted a study extending these findings even further. She found that people will “misremember” additional antecedents that are stereotypically associated with a given outcome; these novel memories reinforce the hindsight bias – their perception that the outcome is inevitable – which affects their judgement of the behaviour and character of the individuals involved. These findings shed light on how & why we judge that people “get what they deserve”, often over-simplistically attributing credit for success and unfairly blaming victims. Continue reading

Five common biology myths (or “Science in the service of the anthropocentric patriarchy”)

Tags

, , , , , , , , ,

In these “enlightened” times, people often try to use science to justify their social, political or ideological positions. While the influence of scientific research on our world view is commonly recognized, the converse dynamic gets far less attention. Cultural factors shape the sort of questions we ask and how we choose to interpret the answers; for example, despite the claim that the idea of evolution has radically altered our view of ourselves, it also often serves to reinforce existing social and cultural norms. Here are five commonly accepted biological “facts” which are untrue but are used to justify our conception of ourselves and our place in the world.

Continue reading

Head to tail: segmenting the body

Tags

, , , , , , , ,

Mouse embryo, 10.5 days old by Alan Boyde (Photo credit: dullhunk)Unlike plants, which can continue to develop new organs and elaborate their body plan throughout their life, animals generally have to contend with a body plan which is fixed at birth.  The basic body plan is laid out during embryogenesis, the intricately choreographed interplay of different processes and mechanisms involved in the development of the embryo.  An important step early in animal embryogenesis is the lengthwise division of the embryo into a series of primitive segments, called somites; each somite will later give rise to vertebrae, skeletal muscle, and dermis, although some of the somites may fuse before this happens.  Correct formation of the somites is a crucial component of the development and is precisely regulated in both space and time.  This tight regulation is accomplished by a remarkably simple, beautiful and ancient mechanism.

Continue reading

Adam & Eve: Behind the Myth

Tags

, , , , , , , , , , ,

Out of Africa (Image via Wikipedia)In a paper published in 1987 in the leading science journal Nature, researchers claimed to have identified a female from whom all humans alive today are descended, dubbed “mitochondrial Eve”; nearly ten years later, another group of scientists published findings identifying her male counterpart, “Y-chromosomal Adam”. The choice of names, though evocative, was unfortunate and uninformative, since the use of “Adam” and “Eve” has led to several major misunderstandings about these two ancient humans.  In this post, I’ll try to clear up some of these misunderstandings by explaining what these terms actually mean and how scientists have gone about trying to identify our most recent common male and female ancestors.

Continue reading

Pointing ravens and theory of mind

Tags

, , , , , , ,

English: Raven (Corvus corax) in Utah, United (Image via Wikipedia)Crows and their relatives have lived alongside us for millenia, becoming an integral part of our mythology and culture, from Gilgamesh and Odin to Chinese myths about the sun.  Many of the birds in the corvid family (which includes magpies, rooks, jackdaws, ravens and, of course, crows) show an impressive level of intelligence.  In addition to using tools, these remarkable birds have shown the ability to recognize individual humans and warn each other about “bad” humans. Now a study by Simone Pika and Thomas Bugnyar has shown that ravens make referential gestures — pointing out items and offering them to other ravens.  While this may sound like relatively mundane behaviour, it’s actually surprisingly rare in non-human animals; our closest relatives, the great apes, don’t seem to do anything similar.  Humans begin to produce and understand referential gestures like pointing around the same time that they start learning language; it’s been suggested that this link isn’t accidental, but represents that it is around this age that human children begin to acquire a theory of mind.  By understanding that other people are also intentional agents — that is, that they also have a mind and act in order to accomplish goals — children are able to overcome many of the difficulties involved in acquiring a language.  Observing referential gestures in ravens not only enhances our understanding of (and respect for) these majestic birds; it also casts our view of the evolution of linguistic pre-requisites in a different light.

Continue reading

Gene expression: shape matters

Tags

, , , , , , , ,

Electron micrograph of Escherichia coli (Image via Wikipedia)A recent paper describes how the mutation of a single gene is sufficient to turn a harmless bacterium found in our gut into an invasive pathogen. Taken alone, this isn’t terribly surprising; many genes regulate the expression of other genes and some (“master” genes) act as switches that control a whole host of other genes.  The gene mutated in this study isn’t one of these “master” genes, though; it’s a structural gene and there’s a much more  intriguing reason for its broad impact on the bacterium.